Right here’s one for the 1Ls on the market gearing up for Contracts.
A charity golf occasion benefitting Nova Southeastern College Orlando provided a Mercedes E Class car as a prize to “Newbie Golfers Solely” who snagged a gap in a single. Undecided why it must be restricted to amateurs. A gap in a single is a fortunate shot. A golfer’s experience is in effectively chaining collectively holes, hitting greens in regulation and a skillful brief sport. However, if that’s within the deal, that’s within the deal.
The plaintiff, Linda Chen, says she hit a gap in a single on the eleventh. That is apparently not in dispute. The match organizer refused to confer the prize.
Chen filed her lawsuit in opposition to Galvin, his firm Event Golf Occasions, Mercedes-Benz of South Orlando, which additionally marketed the prize, and ACE Gap in One, an organization that supplied hole-in-one protection for the match.
Acquired all of the events? Good.
The match organizer claims that it was the indemnifier, ACE Gap in One, who declined to cowl the prize, noting that she labored as knowledgeable golfer.
BUT, she’s an beginner now. In keeping with the USGA, Chen ceased to be knowledgeable and have become an beginner in 2000. So Chen might have been knowledgeable final millennium, however the nationwide sanctioning physique says that title not applies. Barring language within the settlement defining knowledgeable as somebody who has or has ever held skilled standing, which Chen’s attorneys declare doesn’t exist…
Whaddya suppose?
Hole-in-one prize winner sues after she’s denied keys to new Mercedes-Benz in Florida [Miami Herald]
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Legislation and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Be at liberty to electronic mail any suggestions, questions, or feedback. Observe him on Twitter for those who’re serious about legislation, politics, and a wholesome dose of school sports activities information. Joe additionally serves as a Managing Director at RPN Executive Search.
